“This Means War” is one of those movies that is watchable because the concept and the stars hold so much potential – that not even a disastrous directing job can’t totally screw it up.
Love triangles of course have always worked. And with Reese Witherspoon in the middle of the mix, this battle between two likeable, up and coming male stars, Chris Pine and Tom Hardy, has plenty of character charm that almost overcomes the unfathomable directorial execution. I mean, if Captain Kirk and Batman, our heroes current franchises, can’t have fun tussling over a perky blonde, what’s a director, or a Hollywood movie, worth?
Pine and Hardy are a battling duo of CIA agents who go too far on an undercover assignment as the movie opens. They are exiled to Los Angeles for no apparent reason and have nothing better to do than try to find a woman marry. Enter Reese Witherspoon, a bitter marketing expert who’s just been unceremoniously dumped by the boyfriend she moved to LA to marry, but can’t seem unable not to run into on the street.
Her best friend is Chelsea Handler — who prattles away with a misguided, but oh so wise commentary on married life. Every one of these actors is adept at comedy, and the film does have enough love leery, funny moments, but just barely.
Apparently afraid that absurdity and wit couldn’t carry the day, “This Means War” actually has the two guys go to war over Reese. They know they’re chasing the same woman; she doesn’t. A lot of cat and mouse stuff would have sufficed for action. Instead, they go all creepy with total surveillance of one another’s dating adventures — at CIA’s expense.
With the whole Los Angeles CIA operation dedicated to seeing who Reese would sleep with first, one might think some CIA higher up would catch on and shut all this foolishness down. No, it just goes on and on – until a German terrorist saves the plot from total incredulity. Until his return, the movie actually seems realistic if for no other reason than there was not a manical killer in every other scene. When he appears again, it all just falls apart. But thankfully the movie’s almost over and you get to cheer when Reese picks her guy. There is no real surprise in this, but you’ll be happy as long as you don’t think about it too much.
Jealousy of course is the most common of movie emotions. We can all relate — because the stakes in play are true love, and everyone’s done dumb things in the name of love. McG, the director, just directs everything like a music video and misses all the nuances of emotion that would make this movie satisfying, and far more funny. When he cuts a scene like an action movie, you repeatedly feel you’d rather see a love is absurd reaction shot. This happens time and time again.
But then Reese smiles something perky, Chris Pine plays Don Juan, and Tom Hardy pouts like a lovelorn romantic. Hollywood usually provides some sort of romantic comedy around Valentine’s Day, and this will suffice. With a better director, it just would have been so much more fun.